Pulmonary Asbestosis

Our plain-English summary of Pulmonary Asbestosis (1928).

The study

• Published: Journal Of The American Medical Association 90(2):119-120, January 14 (1928)
• Type of article: Editorial
• Our copy: from Johns-Manville's own medical library, J-M no. 003110.

In plain English

This was an unsigned editorial in the Journal of the American Medical Association, not an original study. It described a 1927 case report by W. E. Cooke, which it called only the second reported case of pulmonary asbestosis. A woman began to cough soon after starting work in an asbestos factory at age 13. Her general health did not suffer until 26, she was totally incapacitated five years later, and she died at 33. At postmortem her lungs showed diffuse interstitial pneumonia, chronic bronchitis, some empyema, anthracosis and extensive tuberculosis. They also held unusual foreign bodies thought to be altered portions of asbestos fibers. The editorial said it remained an open question whether the fibrosis came more from tuberculosis or from asbestos, though considerable fibrosis had been found in one case without apparent tuberculosis. It reported an analysis showing that carding-room dust contained 18.4 per cent iron (as ferrous oxide). It also told of a carding-room worker who said he was the only survivor of ten men who had started work with him. It said modern factories now had dust-removal devices.

We wrote this plain-English summary from the full article with the help of AI, and a second AI model checked each sentence against the article. It is not the authors' wording; the abstract and the article are their own account.

What the study did and found

• Design: Editorial commenting on a published case report (W. E. Cooke, British Medical Journal, 1927); not original research
• Who was studied: One woman who worked in an asbestos factory from age 13 and died at 33, as described in Cooke's case report. A second worker, a man who had worked in a carding room for ten years, is also mentioned.
• Exposure: Work in an asbestos factory. The editorial describes dust generated during manufacture, particularly in carding. Chrysotile is named in a garbled composition table comparing Canadian and Italian asbestos.
• Main results:
  • The woman's general health did not suffer until she was 26, and she was totally incapacitated five years later.
  • The woman died at age 33.
  • Postmortem examination of her lungs showed diffuse interstitial pneumonia, chronic bronchitis, some empyema, anthracosis and extensive tuberculosis.
  • Unusual foreign bodies were found in the lungs. The hypothesis advanced was that they were portions of asbestos fibers in the process of alteration.
  • Considerable fibrosis had been found in one case without apparent tuberculosis.
  • An analysis reported in the editorial showed that dust from the carding room contained 18.4 per cent iron (as ferrous oxide).
  • The editorial called Cooke's case only the second reported but said many other cases seemed to have occurred.
  • A patient who had worked in a carding room for ten years said he was the only survivor of ten men who had started work with him.
• The authors' conclusion: The editorial stated that conditions were better at the time, because modern factories were equipped with dust-removal devices. Its following sentence about the dangers of asbestosis is cut off in the scanned text.
• Limitations the authors state:
  • The editorial said it remained an open question whether the woman's lung fibrosis resulted more from tuberculous infection or from asbestos.

Topics

Medical terms in this study, explained in our Lexicon: Asbestosis, Interstitial, Empyema, Anthracosis, Fibrosis, Carding.

Browse return to medical research.