Inhalation toxicity of mineral particles: critical appraisal of endpoints and study design

Our plain-English summary of Inhalation toxicity of mineral particles: critical appraisal of endpoints and study design, by H. Muhle, I. Mangelsdorf (Toxicology Letters, 2003).

The study

• Authors: H. Muhle, I. Mangelsdorf
• Journal: Toxicology Letters
• Published: 2003;140-141:223-8
• Type of article: Review
• Cited by: 8 articles, as counted by NIH iCite
• Read it: PubMed · Publisher

Abstract

Many of the mineral particles that are of concern in regard to lung toxicity are poorly soluble particles (PSPs). They include biopersistent mineral fibers and dusts containing crystalline silica. The preparation of well-defined test particles of respirable size range and their characterization are an essential step that may require more time and effort than the toxicity study itself. For toxicity studies with mineral particles, an investigation of the toxicokinetics is recommended. Such an investigation will yield information that will help to interpret the results if dust overload conditions occur. For mineral particles such as crystalline silica and mineral fibers, an important endpoint is their potential carcinogenicity. The following parameters are important for the design of chronic toxicity studies, and for the prediction of severe chronic effects: lung retention of inhaled materials for assessing the accumulation of particles, persistent inflammation in lungs, persistent proliferation of epithelial lung cells, progressive fibrogenicity, and genotoxicity in the lung cells. These endpoints should indicate whether the materials investigated are of concern in the health effects on exposed humans, and in the effects of the mineral particles for which chronic studies may be required. In addition, this paper focuses on the effects of PSPs combined with fibers, and on the strategies for investigating the potential carcinogenicity of quartz-containing dusts.

In plain English

This 2003 article was a review, not a new study. The authors, from the Fraunhofer Institute of Toxicology and Experimental Medicine in Hannover, Germany, discussed how to design inhalation toxicity tests, mostly in rats, for poorly soluble mineral particles such as asbestos, man-made vitreous fibers and crystalline silica (quartz). They described endpoints including lung retention of particles, persistent inflammation, cell proliferation, fibrosis and genotoxicity. They noted that poorly soluble particles have induced lung tumors in animals only at high lung retention values. In rat experiments by Davis that the authors reviewed, amosite or chrysotile combined with quartz or titanium dioxide caused more fibrosis and pulmonary tumors than the asbestos alone. In a 3-week rat study of refractory ceramic fibers, the sample containing 25% granular dust had a tracer clearance half-time of 1200 days, compared with 80 days for the sample containing 2% dust. The authors recommended subchronic tests before chronic studies of quartz-containing dusts. They concluded that the role of persistent inflammation and reactive oxygen species in particle carcinogenicity needs further investigation.

We wrote this plain-English summary from the full article with the help of AI, and a second AI model checked each sentence against the article. It is not the authors' wording; the abstract and the article are their own account.

What the study did and found

• Design: Review of endpoints and study design for inhalation toxicity testing of mineral particles; no new data collected
• Who was studied: No study population of its own; the review discusses published inhalation toxicity studies, mostly in rats
• Exposure: Poorly soluble mineral particles: mineral fibers (asbestos including amosite and chrysotile, man-made vitreous fibers, refractory ceramic fibers), quartz and quartz-containing dusts (crystalline and amorphous silica), and metal oxides such as titanium dioxide
• Main results:
  • The authors stated that poorly soluble particles have induced lung tumors in animals only at high lung retention values.
  • In rat studies by Davis cited in the review, exposure to amosite or chrysotile with added quartz or titanium dioxide caused more fibrosis and pulmonary tumors than the asbestos samples alone.
  • In a cited 3-week study in female Wistar rats (Bellmann et al., 2001), the refractory ceramic fiber sample RCF1 contained 25% granular dust by weight and RCF1a contained 2%. The particle fraction of RCF1 significantly enhanced the adverse effects.
  • In the same cited study, the alveolar clearance half-time of tracer particles was 1200 days after RCF1 exposure, compared with 80 days after RCF1a exposure.
  • In a cited subchronic rat study (Johnston et al., 2000), genotoxic effects in alveolar epithelial cells appeared after exposure to crystalline silica but not amorphous silica.
  • For quartz-containing materials, the authors recommended starting with subchronic tests as a basis for further testing, before chronic inhalation studies.
• The authors' conclusion: The authors concluded that the role of persistent inflammation and reactive oxygen species in the carcinogenicity of solid particles needs further investigation, and that future study designs should include relevant endpoints.
• Limitations the authors state:
  • The authors stated it remains an open question whether rats are more sensitive to poorly soluble particles than humans.
  • The authors stated it is not totally clear whether dust-overload tumors seen in animals are irrelevant to highly exposed humans such as coal miners or quarry workers.
  • The authors stated it cannot yet be decided whether quartz is a primary carcinogen or acts indirectly.

Topics

Medical terms in this study, explained in our Lexicon: Mineral Fiber, Crystalline, Inflammation, Genotoxicity.

Related studies

• Inhalation toxicity study of disk-shaped potassium octatitanate particles (terracess TF) in rats following 90 days of aerosol exposure — S. Sakai, K. Inada, et al. (2010)
• A comparison of the results from intra-pleural and intra-peritoneal studies with those from inhalation and intratracheal tests for the assessment of pulmonary responses to inhalable dusts and fibres — G. Drummond, R. Bevan, et al. (2016)
• A critical review of the biological mechanisms underlying the in vivo and in vitro toxicity of carbon nanotubes: The contribution of physico-chemical characteristics — H.J. Johnston, G.R. Hutchison, et al. (2010)
• Interleukin 1 production and accessory cell function of rat alveolar macrophages exposed to mineral dust particles — Y. Oghiso, Y. Kubota (1987)
• Mineral properties and their contributions to particle toxicity — G.D. Guthrie (1997)
• Cytotoxic action of mineral dusts on CHV 79 cells in vitro: factors affecting toxicity — S.O. Lock, M. Chamberlain (1983)

Browse more research in Toxicology Letters, or return to medical research.