Mineral properties and their contributions to particle toxicity

Our plain-English summary of Mineral properties and their contributions to particle toxicity, by G.D. Guthrie (Environmental Health Perspectives, 1997).

The study

• Author: G.D. Guthrie
• Journal: Environmental Health Perspectives
• Published: 1997;105 Suppl 5(Suppl 5):1003-11
• Type of article: Review
• Cited by: 37 articles, as counted by NIH iCite
• Read it: PubMed · Publisher · Free full text

Abstract

It has been recognized since at least as early as the mid-1500s that inhaled minerals (i.e., inorganic particles) can pose a risk. Extensive research has focused on the biological mechanisms responsible for asbestos- and silica-induced diseases, but much less attention has been paid to the mineralogical properties and geochemical mechanisms that might influence a mineral's biological activity. Several important mineralogical characteristics control a mineral's reactivity in geochemical reactions and are likely to determine its biological reactivity. In addition to the traditionally considered variables of particle size and shape, mineralogical characteristics such as dissolution behavior, ion exchange, sorptive properties, and the nature of the mineral surface (e.g., surface reactivity) play important roles in determining the toxicity and carcinogenicity of a particle. Ultimately, a mineral's species (which provides direct information on a mineral's structure and composition) is probably one of the most significant yet most neglected factors that must be considered in studies of toxicity and carcinogenicity.

In plain English

This paper was a review based on a 1996 conference presentation. It did not study people. It discussed which mineral properties, as understood in geology and geochemistry, may affect how inhaled mineral particles, including asbestos, cause toxicity and cancer. The author covered mineral species (crystal structure and composition), particle size and shape, sample history, ion exchange, catalysis, oxidation-reduction, dissolution and surfaces. The author argued that differences in biological activity between crocidolite and non-asbestiform riebeckite cannot be attributed only to particle shape, because crocidolite has structural defects. The author also argued that composition, such as how much iron is replaced by magnesium, can vary between samples. The paper described a model by other researchers predicting that chrysotile fibers dissolve completely in days to months under lung-like conditions. It reported preliminary unpublished data from the author and colleagues suggesting that sodium- and potassium-exchanged erionite may be more toxic to rat pleural mesothelial cells at 72 hours than calcium- and iron-exchanged erionite. The author concluded that mineral species is probably one of the most significant yet most neglected factors in studies of toxicity and carcinogenicity.

We wrote this plain-English summary from the full article with the help of AI, and a second AI model checked each sentence against the article. It is not the authors' wording; the abstract and the article are their own account.

What the study did and found

• Design: Narrative review (perspective paper) based on a conference presentation
• Who was studied: No human or animal study population. The paper discusses minerals, including asbestos minerals (crocidolite, amosite, asbestiform tremolite, chrysotile), silica polymorphs, titanium oxides, zeolites such as erionite, and micas.
• Exposure: Mineral properties: mineral species (structure and composition), particle size and shape, sample history, sorption and cation exchange, catalysis, oxidation-reduction, dissolution behavior, and surfaces
• Main results:
  • The author argued that identifying the mineral species used in a study is the minimum sample characterization needed
  • The author argued that, because crocidolite samples generally have many chain-width defects, differences in biological activity between non-asbestiform riebeckite and crocidolite cannot be attributed only to particle morphology
  • The mineral species riebeckite allows up to 50% replacement of iron by magnesium, so the author argued that a compositional analysis must be given for the particular crocidolite sample used in a toxicity study
  • The author described a dissolution model by Hume and Rimstidt (other researchers) predicting that chrysotile fibers dissolve completely in days to months under lung-like conditions
  • Preliminary unpublished data from the author and colleagues suggested that Na- and K-exchanged erionite may be more cytotoxic to rat pleural mesothelial cells at 72 hours than Ca- and Fe-exchanged erionite
  • Titanium dioxide occurs in at least seven different crystal forms, so the author argued that the chemical term alone is inadequate to describe a sample in a toxicity study
• The authors' conclusion: The author concluded that a mineral's species is probably one of the most significant yet most neglected factors to be considered in studies of toxicity and carcinogenicity
• Limitations the authors state:
  • The erionite cation-exchange results are preliminary and unpublished
  • The author noted that few data exist on mineral dissolution kinetics in biological fluids that are based on mechanistic dissolution models
  • The author noted that the kinetics of cation exchange in complex biological fluids are not known
  • A detailed discussion of surface characteristics was outside the scope of the paper

Topics

Medical terms in this study, explained in our Lexicon: Surface Reactivity.

Related studies

• Measurement of elongate mineral particles: What we should measure and how do we do it? — E.J. Chatfield (2018)
• Inhalation toxicity of mineral particles: critical appraisal of endpoints and study design — H. Muhle, I. Mangelsdorf (2003)
• Mechanistic in vitro studies: What they have told us about carcinogenic properties of elongated mineral particles (EMPs) — B.T. Mossman (2018)
• Iron from a geochemical viewpoint. Understanding toxicity/pathogenicity mechanisms in iron-bearing minerals with a special attention to mineral fibers — A.F. Gualtieri, G.B. Andreozzi, et al. (2019)
• Differential responses of murine alveolar macrophages to elongate mineral particles of asbestiform and non-asbestiform varieties: Cytotoxicity, cytokine secretion and transcriptional changes — T.O. Khaliullin, E.R. Kisin, et al. (2020)
• Analysis and identification of elongated mineral particles in road coated aggregates — E. Leocat, C. Rielland, et al. (2018)

Browse more research in Environmental Health Perspectives, or return to medical research.